to the jedi..

[.Artyr.]

hoth

so that you guys dont bitch at me when you say you never saw the thread

 

[Matt]

 

[Dexington]

How very irrelevant, Matt.

 

[Matt]

Hes clappping


So it is relevant....HA!

 

[Cyril Khan]

actually as I now look at this... there is no way they could have reacted so quickly... at least we worked to get info on Hoth, but they didn't on us. That is cheap In my oppinion. Or either I misread that the Jedi are managing to fly through our fleet onto a single capitol ship and ground forces are surviving orbital bombardment to BUILD turrets... yeah, right[/b]

 

[.Artyr.]

added to that comment by cyril admins and jedi, look at my ooc post in the thread.. if your going to rp in a big fight ppl, at least think before you post

 

[Epic]

There, I've edited my post to include any and all things that you want. Should I self destruct the Base now, or later?

And before you say, "You can't just appear in a ship!", remember that the Station is a MOBILE Academy.

 

[Revan The Great]

Originally posted by Kelly
Third, the Sith can't say how much damage is done to the Jedi

Not completly true. There are certain parameters that should be fufilled in an Orbital Bombardment. We can safely say at least several AA-Turrets and possibly some hanger sections have collapsed.

 

[Lillianne Crasse]

Raven, you cannot dictate how much damage is done to the base. We Jedi can direct attacks against your ships and men but we can't dictate how much damage is done to them either. All in all it's fair. You can bombard it and explain how devestating your attack is, but you cannot control the damage aspect. I'm watching to make sure all sides are fair on this. These are the rules and have been for a long time here. This isn't the debate forum.

 

[Shara]

Bugger, why do large battles always have to end up in an argument... *grumbles*

 

[Revan The Great]

Kelly, you miss the point. We bombard, it is expected (And indeed assumed) certain things happen. The extent of the damage is more or less up to the Jedi. But certainly one turret, would be destroyed. Or at least heavy damage to everything on the surface of the bombardment. It is, afterall, Turbolaser fire from a fleet. They cannot say "A few fighters blew up". Or "A turret was scarred with just a burn mark." There is at least a minimum of damage that should be inflicted from an orbital bombardment.

Agreed? Or is that where we differ?

I'm not trying to be a prick, but we ethier differ, or are mistake in our interpretations of each other's view on things. If we differ, I believe my way is completly right, and I should at least try and make you see things my way. If not, fine, but at least I tried.

 

[Drago Solaris]

tbh i partialy agree with revan there should be a quit a bit of damage done atleast but it should be up to the jedi what the damage is done too and how bad it is

 

[Revan The Great]

(Raven) Tis indeed quite a gray area, is it not? A (more or less) large amount of damage should be done. But, the extent of this "large" amount of damage is up to a Jedi. Hence my phrasing of a "Minimum" damage.

Perhaps a better phrasing is this: There is a certain extent of damage that needs to be fufilled to be believible. Going below that is a complete rip-off, and passes into the realm of unbelievibility. I'd go as far as to call it God-modding if the damage was minimal, and overly light. Granted, the complex is mostly underground, so that would be largely uneffected, except maybe a cave-in here or there, or some minor electrical malfunctions. I do believe that just about everything on the surface would be destroyed or severly damaged though. Just look at what Malak did to Taris. Granted, he had a much larger fleet. But then again, he had the target of a whole planet, not a several square mile facility nestled in the mountains.

 

[Lillianne Crasse]

I'm not denying there wouldn't be alot of damage, but he's saying or was in the beginning that they can decide how much is done period. In the past this has caused big huge fights. I even said I would keep an eye on the thread to make sure all sides sound fair. Now question is why is he not liking this whole idea? Khaluq isn't going to respond. I would not play favorites yet I'm not the only one that can keep an eye on this thread either. As a former admin here and now as a swrp advisor, I would think that my knowledge of how to mod things would be trusted as well as the others Jetzt has chosen to be staff members here on this site.

What does irk me is how he's telling staff no. Now, can we all agree here now that the damage is to be decided by the Jedi for Sith attacks and Sith decide damage for Jedi attacks? If it isn't enough for what the attack was in force and power that an admin will comment and it will be changed? THAT is what I'm suggesting and yet I'm being disagreed with. I don't see a problem here.

 

[Raider]

Might as well throw my thoughts into this. After reading only the IC posts (Arytr, Aaron, and Trillin) I can safely say that the Sith nor the Jedi have said anything about what was destoryed and/or damaged on the enemy side. It has only been stated in an OOC post (Raven) that the comm system of the Station has been taken off-line by the orbit bombardment. As OOC posts do not effect IC posts I do not see why everybody is getting all uppity about it. We are still using the honor system, so hopefully before the Jedi launch a counterattack from the Station itself they will comment on how much damage was done. Which is entirely up to them unless the Staff finds something unfair about it.

 

[Ser Yorick]

What the FUCK is going on here? I'm absent for three days and I come back to THIS shit? Someone explain in point form please.

 

[Dexington]

It's all in good fun. Gives you something to react to...

 

[Ser Yorick]

I asked for someone to explain whats going on, how does that explain anything?

 

[Epic]

Sith attack Hoth

We try to defend hoth

sith throw a hissy fit

We try to calm them down

You showed up

Dex didn't explain it

You shot him down

I explained it to you like this:

Sith attack Hoth

We try to defend hoth

sith throw a hissy fit

We try to calm them down

You showed up

Dex didn't explain it

You shot him down

I explained it to you like this:

Sith attack Hoth

We try to defend hoth

 

[Ser Yorick]

Well, how did they attack Hoth in the first place? They're not even done with interrogating Indigo yet, as Uric is about to rescue him, and possibly kill some Sith in the process. Probably finding out about their entire plan to attack Hoth in the first place and have the Republic, and all other allies ready to defend.

To whoever came up with this idea to jump threads and proceed with this retarded idea, don't try and skip ahead on things as huge as this, give other people time to formulate plans, as you have obviously done.

I say, delete the thread, wait 'til the other threads are done, and then try again.